Chit funds - basics

I did a post once -of-p2p.html and keep getting queries about chit funds... so here goes a post which captures the basics of chit funds. (Disclaimer : I claim to be no expert in this and is purely based on my participation in them a few years ago)

A chit fund is a purely Indian invention of accessing money. To that extent I have in the past compared it to peer-to-peer lending. A few people come together, pool a fixed sum of money for a fixed period regularly and every month based on the need, the money is taken by a member. Lets work with an example : Chit A is for 12 months of 1000 each, so the pool available is 12000 (a small technicality, if there are 24 people in the group then 2 chits will be available that month and so on). So all people pay the money to either a designated person or to the chit fund or operator, and then people who require that money bid for it. So if I were to say bid for Rs 1000, then I will get 12000-1000. I now keep paying my 1000 monthly. What happens to the 1000 I paid? - usually a small portion of it goes to the chit fund/operator as charges. The rest are divided amongst the group in either of 2 forms - as a cash payout or as a deduction from the next payment due. Also there is a variation where there is something called a double chit, which is essentially all the bid amount is collected and is available to the group to bid, so that the time period for which you pay the chit is reduced.

What determines the bid amount - multiple factors but most basic is the cost of carry and the demand for money from amongst the group of members. So the bid amounts are usually higher in the initial stages and keep falling, in large chits mostly towards the end bidding does not happen and base bids are fixed. Also most chit have a reserve price and a minimum tick. The demand and supply works differently - if a group consists of mostly businessmen who are looking at short term funding the rates tend to be higher compared to group of housewives - basic concept of benchmark rates and the return that people can get on the money that they took out of the chit. People ask me why shouldnt they just go start a recurring deposit in a bank - both inculcate the same regular saving habit. Simple answer - power of compounding and higher return. Typically if the group you belong to is of people who bid higher then the return on your investment is high and a RD pays you interest in the end, a chit fund is immediate.

But the fundamental laws of finance - risk and return correlation run true here - higher bids mean people are desperate for that cash, which in turn means strained finances (not an issue if it is a temporary cash flow problem) but if it is long term - one runs the risk of default. Also the other problem is of chit fund operators absconding with the money. so the due diligence that you should carry out is check on the operator first and then your group members before you start. Dont bid unless you need the money and have a good use in mind which will pay you more than what you paid them.

The industry is now regulated, so check if the chit is registered and then step into it. Stick to the biggies, there might be safety in numbers. Avoid mom-pop setup unless you trust those guys with your kids.